Dining Out: Bayside American Cafe

A few weeks ago, I headed up to Portland, ME with my best friends from college. We live all over New England and a few times per year we try to get together and explore somewhere new. We've done Hartford, CT, Mystic, CT, Northampton, MA and many more. 

When we decided on Portland, I got straight to work researching restaurant options. The last time I was in that city was three years ago, when my mom and I did a girls weekend for my birthday. We stayed at the Chadwick Bed & Breakfast, which is so charming. I can't recommend it enough. I hope to go back!

We did a lot of good eating on that trip - Standard Baking Co., Holy Donut, Green Elephant, Local 188 and Outliers Eatery

I still had a bunch of things in my "must try" list, so I dusted it off as we planned this getaway. In addition to resurfacing those top picks, I put out a call for ideas on Twitter. The first person to respond was Laura Finaldi, a retail and tourism reporter for the Herald Tribune. She wrote, "Bayside!!! Bayside is a must." I took one look at the menu and knew we had to go there. 

On our first morning in town, we hopped into one car and headed straight for Bayside American Cafe. We were still a block away when we could see the line out front. We put our name in, and the host let us know it would be about 40-45 minutes. He pointed us toward the coffee station, where you are welcome to pour a cup and it take outside with you while you wait. 

We passed the time people watching and taking photos. When the host stuck his head out of the front door and shouted, "Do I have a Molly, part of five?" We shrieked in delight and he said, "Well, that is the most enthusiastic reply I've gotten all morning!" 

We were escorted to a booth on the second floor, toward the back of the dining room. It was at that point we noticed Bayside has a roof deck. You can't see it from the street, but it's there and it would be a lovely place to enjoy a few cocktails. 

Our first order of business was drinks. I think we ordered one of every available cocktail! Between us, we had a bellini, a mango mimosa, a hibiscus cocktail, a Bloody Mary and a peach cooler (that one is booze-free). 

Bayside American Cafe

We all agreed the drinks were huge! Much more generous pours than we're used to receiving at brunch. All of the ladies loved their selections, but I was disappointed by the Bloody Mary. It didn't have any zest or kick. A friend suggested I sprinkle in some salt, which did help. 

We placed our food order (savory egg dishes all around, plus one sweet thing to share) and in a delightful turn of events, our waitress brought our French toast first! 

This is the strawberry cheesecake French toast, and I am drooling just looking at it again. 

Bayside American Cafe

The cheesecake icing was decadent and the strawberries added a nice, tart contrast to every bite. If you got a bite without icing, it was a bit dry. Thankfully there was local maple syrup available to solve that problem! 

The first of the savory dishes to arrive was the roasted root vegetable hash. They offer it in both a full and half portions. My friend went with the half. 

Bayside American Cafe

A few bites in she said, "I don't usually go for a vegetarian breakfast option, but this was worth it! They let me get hollandaise sauce on the side, which I appreciated. I loved the scallions - they added a great pop of flavor. I also asked for a side of extra crispy bacon, and it did not disappoint." 

Next to her, a friend had made her own omelette, requesting mushrooms, broccoli, olives and roasted garlic. When the plate landed in front of her, she said, "This is interesting, this is more like a crepe. It tastes very light, not greasy at all. The roasted garlic was the best part. I also enjoyed the homemade bread on the side. It was so fresh it didn't even need butter." 

Bayside American Cafe

Across from me, a friend was delivered the huevos rancheros. As soon as I saw her plate, I wished I had ordered it. 

Bayside American Cafe

She described the dish as, "Scrumptious," and continued on to say, "The pico de gallo, sour cream and guacamole ratio was excellent. The egg and rice and beans were delicious. I wasn't into the tortilla being grilled, I would have preferred they left it fresh." 

To my left, a friend was about to cut into the lobster eggs benedict. When in Maine!

Bayside American Cafe

She took a few bites and shared, "There wasn't a ton of lobster here. I was surprised the spinach on the benedict was raw, I was expecting it to be sauteed. That said, the hollandaise sauce was great and the eggs were cooked perfectly. The potatoes were crispy and seasoned well." 

I went with the veggie eggs benedict. Most brunch places offer some rendition of this, but it's typically just a tomato and avocado, or tomato and spinach. The Bayside version has tomato, spinach, portobello mushrooms, button mushrooms, summer squash, broccoli, red onion and red pepper. Now, I know you are asking yourself, "How can they possibly fit all those veggies on an English muffin?" I have no idea, but it's a breakfast miracle. 

Bayside American Cafe

I loved the dish, including the home fries on the side. 

We all agreed that the food at Bayside was worth the long wait. We also appreciated the kindness of every member of their team - from the host who never got annoyed when we asked how many people were ahead of us on the list, to our waitress who delighted us with the French toast appetizer, to the bar back who noticed one of us dropped a knife, and was over in a flash, picking it up before she could even bend down to retrieve it. 

Bayside is open each week, Thursday - Tuesday, from 7:00am - 2:00pm. I highly recommend arriving before 10:00am to cut down on wait time. 

Thank you to Laura for this killer recommendation! 


Robin Jack's picture

Avenue South Residence is a brand-new masterpiece situated at Silat Avenue in Bukit Merah jointly developed by consortium which comprises of UOL, UIC and Kheng Leong Company. Sitting on a huge plot of land, the 2-tower block with 56 storey will yield 1,074 units! Aspiring buyers will definitely be able to secure a choice unit from 1-bedroom to 5-bedroom type of layout. Avenue South Residence also have a commercial component that comprises of childcare and commercial shops. avenue south floorplan

Robin Jack's picture

The Florence Residence is a brand new condo, with 128 condo facilities, situated in Kovan developed by Logan Property Holdings Company Limited. A Hong Kong-based property developer, Logan have built an impressive portfolio in the residential segment in the People's Republic of China (PRC) such as Hong Kong and GuangdongThe Florence Residences is strategically located along Hougang Avenue 2 that is accessible to 2 MRT station, Kovan and Hougang. There are plenty of amenities, such as shopping malls, supermarkets, hawker centres, cafes, which are walking distance from The Florence Residences. Florence residences condo

Robin Jack's picture

Mayfair Modern is a new launch property located at 2 Rifle Range Road. The new Bukit Timah Condo comprises a total of 171 units consisting of units from 1 to 4 bedroom layouts.Mayfair Modern is located at the prime district Bukit Timah, within a mere 3 minutes stroll to King Albert Park MRT. Several shopping facilities and amenities can readily be found within the vicinity of Mayfair Modern Condo such as Bukit Timah Shopping Centre, Bukit Timah Plaza, Coronation Plaza, and more.Future Residents of Mayfair Modern Condo will find several renowned schools within such as Methodist Girls' School and Pei Hwa Presbyterian Primary School.Several units were successfully sold during the Mayfair Modern launch on 6th April 2019. You may read more in depth about the condominium here - Mayfair Modern: New Waves of Premium Homes at Bukit Timah.Aspiring home owners may now view and download Mayfair Modern Floor Plan&Mayfair Modern E-Brochure. mayfair modern floor plan

Robin Jack's picture

This is really interesting, I’ll check out your other posts! Doanh Nhân Trẻ Việt Nam

Robin Jack's picture

not everyone would need a nose job but my girlfriend really needs some rhinoplasty coz her nose is kind of crooked- Balo học sinh cấp 1

Robin Jack's picture

Some truly wonderful content on this web site , appreciate it for contribution. báo doanh nhân trẻ Việt Nam

Log in to comment


Molly Galler

Welcome to Pop.Bop.Shop. My name is Molly. I’m a foodie, fashionista, pop culture addict and serious travel junkie. I’m a lifelong Bostonian obsessed with frozen confections, outdoor patios, Mindy Kaling, reality television, awards shows, tropical vacations, snail mail and my birthday.

More from Molly

Pop.Bop.Shop. In the News